Supreme Court rules inherited IRAs not protected from creditors

July 15, 2014 by Carolyn Richardson, EA, MBA
Supreme Court

In all the hoopla surrounding the Supreme Court’s decision in the Hobby Lobby case, it probably escaped everyone’s notice that the Court issued an earlier decision on June 14, 2014, regarding whether inherited IRAs are protected when a taxpayer declares bankruptcy, or from other claims of creditors. This decision is likely to impact many taxpayers, particularly anyone expecting to inherit an IRA from a parent or someone else.

The case, Clark v. Rameker, involved a taxpayer who had filed for bankruptcy. Under the bankruptcy code, certain “retirement funds” are exempt from the bankruptcy estate. In other words, these accounts are not considered to be assets that can be used to pay off creditors if you have to declare bankruptcy. Both traditional and Roth IRAs are normally exempt from bankruptcy.

If your spouse dies and you inherit their IRA, you have the option of rolling over the funds to your own IRA, and at that point it becomes your IRA. Any distributions you make from that IRA are treated the same as they would if you had put the money into the account yourself. If you inherit the IRA from someone other than your spouse, though, you only have the option of holding the account as an inherited IRA, taking Required Minimum Distributions each year or withdrawing all of the funds within 5 years of your benefactor’s death. The holder of an inherited IRA may withdraw funds from the IRA at any time and for any reason, at any age, without paying the 10% early distribution penalty.

In the Clark case, Heidi Heffron-Clark inherited an IRA worth $450,000 from her mother, who died in 2001. In 2010, she and her husband declared bankruptcy when the account was worth $300,000. They sought to exempt this account from their bankruptcy estate, and their creditors filed an objection. Several appeals courts disagreed with each other, which is why it ended up at the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court agreed with the 7th Circuit’s earlier decision that “inherited IRAs represent an opportunity for current consumption, not a fund of retirement savings.” In other words, the beneficiary of an inherited IRA can withdraw money at any time for any reason, not just for retirement.

So, if you have an inherited IRA and are thinking of claiming bankruptcy, keep this in mind. Those funds can be used by the bankruptcy estate to pay off debt. If the funds would be enough to pay off your debts, you might as well use them that way and avoid bankruptcy completely and the credit ramifications that come with it.



Carolyn Richardson, EA, MBA
Learning Content Managing Editor


Carolyn has been in the tax field since 1984, when she went to work at the IRS as a Revenue Agent. Carolyn taught many classes at the IRS on both tax law changes and new hire training. In 1990, she left the IRS for a position at CCH, where she was a developer on both the service bureau software and on the Prosystevm fx tax preparation software for nearly 17 years. After leaving CCH she worked at several Los Angeles-based CPA firms before starting at TaxAudit as an Audit Representative in 2009. Carolyn became the manager of the Education and Research Department in 2011, developing course materials for the company and overseeing the research requests. Currently, she is the Learning Content Managing Editor. 


Recent Articles

Refund check laying on top of a $100 bill
An IRS Notice CP32A is informing you that your refund check has not been claimed. To resolve this notice, you must call to request a new refund check.
Woman Reading Letter
IRS Notice CP21C is sent out when a taxpayer requests to make a change to their tax return. The notice informs the taxpayer that the change has been completed.
House for Sale
Details regarding the disposition of grouping of activities in order to more easily satisfy the material participation requirements for the RE Pro status.
Man opening a letter
IRS CP06A notice asks you to verify the Premium Tax Credit you claimed on your tax return with documentation. How should you properly respond to this notice?
This blog does not provide legal, financial, accounting, or tax advice. The content on this blog is “as is” and carries no warranties. TaxAudit does not warrant or guarantee the accuracy, reliability, and completeness of the content of this blog. Content may become out of date as tax laws change. TaxAudit may, but has no obligation to monitor or respond to comments.